Anatomy of a Mobile-First Responsive Web Design

Mobile First Responsive Web Design

Last month I had the opportunity to contribute to Google’s HTML5 Rocks site with an article called Creating a Mobile-First Responsive Web Design. In the article, I walk through step-by-step the process of creating an adaptive website that does its best to take context into consideration.

While the tutorial goes over the construction of the experience, this article will take a look at the responsive/UX considerations of the demo. To do this, I’ve created a feature on the demo that annotates (almost) every element on the page, explaining why the element exists on the page, and also what was considered when incorporating the element into the design. You can toggle annotations by clicking the red area that says “Annotations Off”, which is either fixed in the bottom right corner of the demo on larger screens, or below the site footer on smaller screens.

So without further ado, I will walk step by step through every element in the demo.

Masthead

Header

Header

The main header of the site doesn’t take up too much screen real estate in order to keep the focus on the core content. It’s using a linear CSS gradient instead of a background image to give greater design flexibility and reduce HTTP requests.

Logo

Logo

The logo image is purposefully larger and scaled down to the final dimensions. Keeping image file sizes as small as possible is extremely important, but loading in a slightly larger image ensures image crispness on Retina and other high resolution displays. The file size difference is usually negligible and ensures a positive aesthetic first impression. So while you wouldn’t necessarily want to do this for every image on the page, it makes sense for something as important as a logo.

See also: Optimizing Web Experiences for High Resolution Screens

Primary Navigation

Nav

Navigation for adaptive web experiences can be tricky. Top navigations are typical on desktop sites, but mobile screen sizes don’t give us the luxury of space. We’re dealing with this situation by creating a simple menu anchor that toggles the main navigation on small screens. This is just one method. Bagcheck and Contents Magazine add an anchor in the header that jumps users to the navigation which is placed in the footer. This solution works well because it doesn’t require any Javascript in order to work.

Other methods exist too. For example, ESPN’s mobile navigation overlays the main content of the page. The nav is only hidden when a certain level of javascript is supported in order to ensure that users with little/poor javascript support can still access the navigation. Once the screen size is large enough to accommodate the nav, we show the main navigation links and hide the menu anchor.

See also: Responsive Navigation Patterns

Search Box

Search

Search is an incredibly important priority, especially for mobile. It is a great idea to give users the ability to jump directly to what they are looking for without forcing them to wade through your site’s navigation. Check out the Burton and Yelp mobile sites for great examples of experiences that prioritize search.

We’re also using the HTML5 search input type, which is great for mobile devices that can bring up the appropriate virtual keyboard for many smartphones. And like the main header navigation, we’re hiding the search form on small screens to save space. Clicking the search anchor toggles the form.

Image Gallery

Image Navigation

Image Navigation

Instead of providing bullets, pagination or text-based image navigation, it’s good e-commerce practice to show a preview of the various product views. By default the images simply link through to their larger counterparts, and if adequate javascript support exists, the images get loaded into the main image container.

Product Image

Main Image

The product image is the focal point of the page for good reason. It’s typically what the user is there to see. The default markup simply includes the main product image, but that gets replaced with an image gallery if adequate javascript support exists.

We’re also using Modernizr to detect if the browser supports touch events and if it does, we load in an excellent lightweight script called Swipe.js to create a touch-friendly image carousel. This allows users to swipe between product photos in a touch-friendly way. Because gestures are invisible, they might get overlooked, but clicking on the image navigation thumbnails animates the slideshow and hints to the user gestural interaction is available.

Product Description

Product Overview

product overview

The product overview appears in the markup before the image container in order to provide the user with the product name, how much it costs and how popular it is. Providing this information as soon as possible can help the user determine whether or not this is the product they’re looking for without having to wait for the rest of the page to load.

Rating Stars

Rating Stars

We’re using HTML special characters to display the product rating stars. We’re using HTML characters instead of images to reduce the amount of images we’re requesting and also maintaining crispness on high resolution screens. Not every device supports HTML special characters (Blackberry <=5.0 for example), but support is strong enough and the benefits are many.

See also: Optimizing Web Experiences for High Resolution Screens

Review Count

This is a simple anchor link that points to the review section of the page. This may seem like a small detail, but consider a mobile use case. Users can be in stores looking at the physical product, and 79% of smartphone consumers use their phones to help with shopping. They might be interested in buying in-store but turn to their phones to verify its popularity and quality. Making it easy for uses to read product reviews on small screens can help drive more sales, both online and offline.

While not incorporated yet, it would be easy to load the reviews for small screens on demand, thereby saving an extra click.

Quantity Field

Quantity Field

We’re using the HTML5 number input type, which brings up the appropriate virtual keyboard for many mobile browsers. To increase usability, the input labels are using the “for” attribute, which focuses the cursor in the form field when clicked. However, iOS doesn’t honor “for” default functionality, so we’re adding “cursor: pointer” to the labels to get Mobile Safari to behave properly.

Size Dropdown

Size Dropdown

We’re using a basic select menu to choose the size, which is commonplace for any e-commerce site. Select menus can be especially difficult to style and can vary greatly in behavior between platforms. Keep this in mind when styling select menus.

Add to Cart Button

Add To Cart Button

The add to cart button is the primary user action on the page. That’s why it’s large and in charge and very prominently placed on the page. The button is using box-shadows and rounded corners to create an attractive button that will hopefully get plenty of clicks.

Share Button

Share Icons

It seems like everything has a share button on it these days. And for good reason. Sharing content and products on social networks can be a great way to increase exposure. However, tacking on tons of social widgets adds a lot of overhead, which can be extremely detrimental to the site’s performance. Including a simple share link that loads the heavy widgets only when requested is one way to keep pages fast and social. Check out Target’s mobile site for an example of a site that isolates share functionality in a separate page fragment.

Auxiliary Information

Related Products

Responsive Web Design Related Products

Related products are obviously an important aspect of e-commerce sites as they drive awareness of other similar products and can lead to more purchases. However, including a lot of auxiliary content can bog down the site performance, which is especially crucial on mobile. On slow connections, the presence of this extra content might slow down the user experience enough that the user gives up.

We’re handling the issue by conditionally loading the auxiliary content.

By default, the related item link simply clicks through to an HTML fragment containing the related products. The content is still accessible, even on devices with poor or no javascript support. When the user clicks on the related products on small screens, the content gets dynamically loaded inline and the link becomes a toggler for the content. Once the experience reaches a certain width breakpoint, we then load in the content. However, screen size != fast connection, so we should keep our eyes on the emerging navigator.connection to better gauge real connection speed.

See also: An Ajax-Include Pattern for Modular Content

All these wonderful t-shirts are retired/rejected Busted Tees, graciously donated to this demo by Will Schneider.

Product Reviews

Product Reviews

Reviews can greatly influence a user’s decision to purchase a product or pass on it. Also, because we carry our mobile phones with us everywhere, we use them to inform our in-store purchases. 79% of smartphone owners use their phones to help with shopping, from comparing prices, finding more product info to locating a retailer.

Only the primary product content gets loaded by default, and the reviews exist as their own separate HTML fragment. The reviews remain accessible and don’t get loaded until we conditionally load them when the screen is large enough or small screen users click the reviews link. This keeps things nimble while still providing access to the valuable reviews.

See also: An Ajax-Include Pattern for Modular Content

More Reviews Link

Read All Reviews Button

All reviews aren’t loaded by default in order to keep the site performance in top shape. Ultimately, this button could be replaced with a lazy-loading solution to remove the need for the button.

Footer

Footer Navigation

Footer Nav

Repetition of elements isn’t necessarily a bad thing, especially with potentially long scrolling pages on mobile. Providing access to the main site navigation is a good way for the user to jump off to another section and avoids leaving them at a dead end. Also, some mobile sites like Bagcheck and Contents Magazine keep the primary navigation at the footer and simply link to it with an anchor in the header. That way the nav stays accessible but the focus stays on on the core page content.

Customer Service Number

Customer Service Number

We sometimes forget that mobile phones can make phone calls. Whether a user is having trouble with the site or simply has some questions about the product he’s about to buy, it’s a smart decision to provide a clickable phone number to facilitate that call. What happens when desktops and other non-phone devices click on the tel link? Well, some devices (like iPads and other tablets) ask the user if they’d like to add the number to their contact list, other desktops open 3rd party VoIP programs like Skype, and others simply give an error message.

Back to Top Link

Back to Top Link

Back to top links are simple yet underrated. They provide users with an easy way back up to the top of the page with minimum effort. This is especially helpful on mobile devices, which tend to have long scrolling pages.

We’re using an HTML character for the back to top arrow in order to reduce image elements and keep things looking crisp on high res displays.

Wrapping Up

So there you have it. Every element of a mobile-first responsive web design explained from a user experience point of view. If you’re more interested in reading how the site was built, please read the tutorial on the HTML5 Rocks site. And again, feel free to check out the demo and play with the annotations.

14 Comments

  1. This is a great post. Thank you for sharing. Just one thing to mention about the demo…

    When the header hits the breakpoint for hiding the “menu” and “search” buttons, there is a few pixels of a gap before the breakpoint for displaying the full nav and search box. So effectively, if the browser window is at the perfect (read: unfortunate) size, there is nothing in the header aside from the logo.

    Tested in FF & Chrome.

  2. Brett S

    There are lots of great suggestions here.
    Thanks Brad.

  3. A very good read for beginners like me. Thanks!

  4. Ian Glass

    Thanks for the run down, but don’t forget proxy browsers.

    They, or at least Opera Mini, support Javascript but they process it on the server rather than on the phone. That means that any content hiding that relies on Javascript will cause a round trip to the server. If I click on the menu link, I have to wait for the entire page to reload before I can see the navigation, which is a suboptimal experience (although that’s certainly much better than hiding content all together).

    In the case of site navigation, I think that Contents does it well since intrapage links work without a server round trip. I get quick access to both the site navigation and the thing that I’m reading.

    Also consider that – since it would be a royal pain to wait for a full refresh every time you scroll – onscroll events aren’t implemented. And setInterval doesn’t run after the page is rendered (remember Javascript only runs on the server). Lazy loading simply doesn’t work in Opera Mini, and I would assume Kindle Fire or any other proxy browser, so I would advise not scraping the ‘Load More Reviews’ button or simular functionality. Tumblr, for instance, is awful about that since it seems that many of the theme devs are so besotted by lazy-loading wizardry that they forget to include a fallback.

    Anyway, I just wanted to toss my two cents in.

  5. Björn Allvin

    Thanks for the awesome article. Finally a nice e-commerce example. There aren’t that many out there. Do you have any tips on good e-commerce sites using responsive design?

    Thanks again!

  6. Michael Hessling

    You could make your own share button, too. It’s essentially just a set of links (even though these links are becoming deprecated–see Facebook’s Share link).

    I’m curious about your use of jQuery. I’m trying really hard to load jQuery only when the screen meets a certain size (my assumption, weak as it may be, is that larger screen is better bandwidth). I simply don’t see the need for jQuery on a mobile site (especially ours, which is not commerce, but content).

  7. Rob W

    @Michael, I’m with you on keeping page weight as low as possible, but if you’re serving jQuery from a popular (google) CDN there’s a good chance that the user has it cached already. If they do, you’re getting easier to write, more maintainable code for free.

    Maybe there are special caching considerations for mobile browsers though, that I could not tell you.

  8. Great post thanks. I like the choice in template too, but I would agree with michael on branding the share buttons as well. It is always a nice added touch, plus it gives you the ability to draw a little more attention to them.

  9. You really think that a miniscule 960 streak down the middle of a landscape oriented desktop monitor and 50% margins fits the definition of “Responsive” – I think not.

  10. On Android device (I use HTC desier z) when you tap on numer select field the page goes crazy, it scroll from botom to top back and forth.

  11. Nice article… In short planning.
    I have just finished our first responsive website.
    It took a while to get through what we needed to see and what is just stuff.

  12. Awesome writing. I am stepping into mobile first approach and this is an awesome guide for anyone starting. Thanks a lot :-) will come back with feedback.

  13. Oliver

    Any chance you could put this up on github for others to use/contribute to?

  14. @dj, responsive does not dictate a max width of 100%. A fluid grid can still be inside a container. The site works on a mobile screen, tablet screen, and desktop screen, which is the whole point of being responsive, no matter what “definition” you follow.